Last month, I was invited to be the speaker at a school in New York City where the seniors had just completed their capstone projects. This was the inaugural year for senior capstones, and the high school was gathered to celebrate. It just so happened that this was also my alma mater.
As I prepared my remarks to the students, I realized how much I would have loved to do a capstone project during my senior year at this school, and I knew exactly what it would have been. I would have wanted to do a project focused on bringing about the Star Trek future – a future in which our planet is thriving, our nations are at peace, bigotry is vanquished, and we’ve solved our most devastating problems. (I can only hope that no teacher would have told me to choose a less pie-in-the-sky capstone.)
I asked the students if they’d heard of Star Trek. While most had, only one raised her hand when I asked if there were any fellow fans. Oh well. Times change. Earlier that day, on my way to meet with a woman at UNESCO to discuss a potential collaboration with the Institute for Humane Education, I walked down the street where the Federation Trading Post – New York City’s Star Trek store from 1975-1977 – was located in a second-floor storefront. I worked there when I was in high school. Now there was a shiny modern skyscraper where that building once stood.
I knew I risked appearing like the least cool speaker they’d ever heard by telling them about my Star Trek obsession, so I was unprepared for their response when I admitted that I once asked William Shatner, who played Captain Kirk on the original series, to kiss me in front of 5,000 people at a Star Trek convention. At first there was an audible gasp. Then some titters and nervous laughter. And then suddenly the whole auditorium erupted in applause. Who knew that teenagers would be inspired to cheer a sixty-three-year-old who was willing to publicly humiliate herself when she was their age?
But then things got a little darker. I asked them to raise their hands if they thought that the aspects of the Star Trek future that I described – where we’d, by and large, built a peaceful, healthy planet – was likely in their lifetimes. Only a small number raised their hands.
And so the rest of my presentation was devoted to trying to change their minds enough so that they would have the necessary hope to take action, because without action, all of our collective despair is surely warranted. I described how so many things had changed for the better since I grew up and went to their school, and I invited them to ask themselves, “What difference do I want to make?” rather than “What do I want to be?”
The rest of my presentation was devoted to trying to change their minds enough so that they would have the necessary hope to take action, because without action, all of our collective despair is surely warranted.
I also told them about Mahatma Gandhi’s response to a reporter when asked, “What is your message?” and how Gandhi jotted down on a piece of paper, “My life is my message.” I remarked that this simple sentence is true for all of us and encouraged them to consider what message they wanted to convey in their lives. I ended with a visualization I often share at presentations, inviting the students to imagine that they’re very old and living in a much better world where there hasn’t been a war in as long as they can remember; where no one goes to bed hungry; and where we’ve learned to treat other people and animals with respect and compassion. I then asked them to imagine a child asking them what they did to help bring about such a future. That simple act of visualizing a better world and knowing one played a part in its unfolding works wonders for generating hope.
What’s key to that visualization, however, is answering the child’s question: “What did you do?” because hope isn’t enough. One can easily imagine too much hope and too little action, which creates the illusion that somebody or something will make things right and that it’s okay to abdicate responsibility for our actions and for our impacts on other people, other animals, and our shared Earth. As the writer Grace Paley wrote: “The only recognizable feature of hope is action.”
Education that gives students the skills and opportunities to solve real-world problems conveys to them: What you do matters… And it conveys not only that you matter, but that you are capable of creating real change.
Education that gives students the skills and opportunities to solve real-world problems conveys to them: What you do matters. It matters that you care and that you act; that you seek common ground, consider multiple viewpoints, and don’t accept existing divisions and destructive systems as permanent. And it conveys not only that you matter, but that you are capable of creating real change.
Renato, a high school student in Chile, recently shared with a group of educators that he and his classmates used to think they would be the last generation on Earth—until they had the experience of working on a solutionary project. During that project, their perspective shifted as they were invited not only to learn about a problem they care about, but also to take actionable steps to contribute to change. They now realize positive change is possible. Nobody told Renato he needed to have hope; hope was a result of his actions and the actions of his community.
If you want to help students build hope based on action, check out the Solutionary Framework, which you can use to lead solutionary projects in your classroom or community.
